Why some behaviors aren’t problems — they’re biology
Many dog owners spend years trying to “fix” behaviors that were never broken to begin with. Digging, barking, chasing, sniffing, guarding resources, and even selective listening often get labeled as bad habits — when in reality, they are deeply wired survival instincts.
Trying to eliminate these behaviors doesn’t just fail — it can increase anxiety, confusion, and behavioral fallout.
Here’s what instinctive dog behaviors you should manage, redirect, or respect — never erase.
_____
1. Sniffing Everything (Yes, Everything)
To humans, sniffing looks like distraction.
To dogs, it’s information gathering.
Dogs process the world primarily through scent — not sight.
Sniffing allows dogs to:
read emotional states
identify territory
assess safety
reduce stress
mentally decompress
🚫 Trying to rush or stop sniffing often leads to frustration and reactivity.
What to do instead:
Schedule “sniff walks” where speed doesn’t matter.
2. Barking (It’s a Communication Tool, Not Defiance)
Dogs bark for different reasons:
alerting
excitement
fear
boredom
frustration
Silencing barking without understanding why it happens often worsens behavior.
🚫 Punishing barking teaches fear — not quiet.
What to do instead:
Identify the trigger and redirect the behavior, rather than suppressing it.
3. Chasing Moving Objects
Squirrels. Bikes. Cars. Leaves.
Chasing is a prey-drive behavior, not stubbornness.
High-chase dogs aren’t “bad listeners” — their brains are temporarily hijacked by instinct.
🚫 Trying to punish chasing creates anxiety around movement.
What to do instead:
Use long leashes, impulse-control games, and safe outlets like flirt poles.
4. Digging
Digging serves multiple purposes:
temperature regulation
stress relief
boredom release
den-making instincts
Some breeds are literally designed to dig.
🚫 Blocking all digging often creates alternative destructive outlets.
What to do instead:
Create a designated digging zone or enrichment alternatives.
5. Guarding Valued Resources
Resource guarding is normal survival behavior.
Dogs guard:
food
toys
space
resting areas
The goal is not elimination — it’s trust.
🚫 Forcing items away increases guarding intensity.
What to do instead:
Build positive associations with human presence near resources.
6. Herding Behavior
Nipping heels, circling, controlling movement — herding dogs weren’t meant to be passive pets.
🚫 Suppressing herding instincts causes frustration and anxiety.
What to do instead:
Channel herding energy into structured tasks, agility, or training games.
7. Alertness to Sounds and Movement
Dogs evolved to notice threats before humans.
Reacting to noises, shadows, or changes in environment is protective instinct.
🚫 Punishing alert behavior teaches dogs that noticing danger is wrong.
What to do instead:
Teach calm acknowledgment and reward disengagement.
Why “Untraining” Instincts Backfires
Instinct suppression often leads to:
anxiety
reactivity
shutdown behavior
compulsive behaviors
loss of trust
Behavior doesn’t disappear — it re-emerges in worse forms.
Instinct Management vs. Instinct Suppression
The healthiest dogs aren’t the most obedient — they’re the most understood.
Good training:
works with instincts
provides safe outlets
teaches regulation, not denial
respects breed traits
Understanding instinct makes training easier — not harder.
Final Thought
Dogs aren’t misbehaving when they follow instinct — they’re being dogs.
The goal of training isn’t control.
It’s cooperation.
When instinct is respected and redirected, dogs become calmer, more confident, and easier to live with — without losing who they are.
